bc4life,I agree with what John says about proving the oil failed. If your motor is still under warranty, Id stick with what Mercury recommends. If it is out of warranty, it doesnt matter because any engine failure falls to you. Im probably safe in saying Mercury doesnt have any oil refineries, etc. but if Im wrong, I apologize. Someone is making Mercurys oil and it could very well be Amsoil – both companies are located in Wisconsin. My Mercury motor is out of warranty and Ive been using Amsoil synthetic oil in the lower gear case and oil injection HP Amsoil for my engine. I burn the highest octaine fuel I can buy, usually 91-93 – no ethanol. Im able to scope my engine every year. The boat and motor was four years old when I purchased them. The cylinder and cylinder walls look better than when I purchased the boat. Ive noticed where the engine exhausts through the prop, was very black when I got the boat. AFter a few runs using the Amsoil, that portion of the prop is clean. There are a lot of good oils on the market. Ive used several in my off-road vehicle and racing engines. Ive been with Amsoil for a number of years and havent had any problems. Best of luck