JaimeB, I have a 2017 Cougar AE. I also have power poles, 2 graphs in the front (10″ Garmins), 1 12″ Garmin at the console, livescope and the Garmin Hub. I ran 10 gauge TINN wire from the back of the boat to the front and put all of my electronics on a separate fuse panel to include the livescope and the hub. I also separately switched my garmin trolling motor foot control, and livescope so I know that they have no power running to them when I shut them off (parasitic drain). I would start with a volt meter at the battery, (while either you are at home or make a trip to the lake specifically to check the electronics drain), disconnect all power leads to the graphs and run the poles up and down to see what the voltage is. You can disconnect the graphs simply by unplugging them at the back of each graph. At the back of the rocker switch at the bilge area to turn on power for the poles make sure that the connections going to that switch are good. Both poles should go through that switch and it almost sounds like if they are crimped together that the connection for the hot on both poles has been compromised in some way. Another way to check it would be to probe both hot wires when you cycle the pumps up and down to see what you have for voltage on both leads going to the pumps, they both should mirror each other. The rocker switch should illuminate when you turn on the poles and you should hear a tone coming from the pumps that indicate they are ready to go. The black wire should be a ground wire to complete a circuit for the light on the switch.