Maybe – maybe not…. The older 150efi was a “fatter” stronger motor than the Optis and it may be able to turn it. Ive run a 24 Fury on my Sabre / 150efi and it turned it just fine. A P2 is heavier than my Sabre. What I could tell is that the Fury took longer to get to speed – but was slightly faster on top. I run a 24 worked Tempest typically and find it to be a better all around prop. The Tempest lifts better, carries load better, and turns easier on my hull.