You have a rare combination with the 225 HO Evinrude. Most came with 24” propellers we think and we probably would even run a 23” if one was found. Availability to actual OMC/BRP propellers will be limited as they get eaten up during low supply. You can run a Fury in that case and you might try a 24” Fury with an Evinrude hub kit.
The Caracal will “eat” or work with many propellers and has a wide range of performing propellers.
We would play with it some and try to find a smaller three blade. We do find the 25” to be too large on Caracal models, even with the strong torque curve the Evinrude has.