Definitely don’t choose based on internet pics. Need to see any of them out in some sunlight to get the real impression. At least get outdoors with the dealer samples and put them side by side, take a few steps back, etc. I was in your shoes a few years ago and ended up with charcoal mist. Black fox looked like more silver flake to my eyes, but maybe it is larger flake also? I have heard some refer to it as darker than the charcoal, so go figure. On my charcoal cap colors come out in the sun that you would never expect based on how it looks in the garage. Great color, I love it, and get compliments all the time but still wonder if I should have gone black fox sometimes. Will probably keep me awake again when I upgrade next year haha.